BS EN 287-1 vs BS EN ISO 9606-1 WPQR

ISO 9606-1 has been cited in the Official Journal of the European Union as harmonized with the Pressure Equipment Directive (PED), with effect from 1 March 2018.

This FAQ gives a quick summary of the transition between the standards for welder qualification BS EN 287-1 and BS EN ISO 9606-1 and provides recommendations on how to apply them.

Please note that this article is not authorized to give official interpretations of BS EN ISO standards and the answer below is an opinion only, and cannot be taken as a definitive answer. No liability rests with this post for any damages arising from this communication.

Status of BS EN 287-1 and BS EN ISO 9606-1

  • The status of BS EN 287-1 according to BSI is ‘Current, superseded’.
  • ‘Current’ means that EN 287-1 can be used. ‘Superseded’ means that another standard has been issued, which is more up-to-date. In this case, ISO 9606-1 has been issued. ‘Superseded’ does not mean ‘withdrawn’.
  • When EN ISO 9606-1 was issued, the relevant European pressure vessel committees did not agree with the wording of Annex ZA, which addresses conformity with the Pressure Equipment Directive (PED, 2014/68/EU), so EN ISO 9606-1 was not included in the Official Journal of the EU as a harmonized standard.
  • The wording of Annex ZA was discussed and approved by the relevant CEN and ISO committees, and BS EN ISO 9606-1 was issued in September 2017 with the approved Annex ZA.
  • According to Annex ZA: Clause 9.3(c) option (c) for revalidation is not be permitted for Category II, III and IV products.
  • EN ISO 9606-1 is now harmonized with the PED and the Simple Pressure vessel Directive (SPVD).
  • BS EN 287-1 is still listed as ‘Current’ by BSI because it is still referenced in product standards, as well as contracts, specifications.

NOTE 1: the authors are not aware of the status of harmonization of ISO 9606 1:2017 with the Construction Products Regulations (CPR), Machinery Directive, Rail Vehicles, etc.

Recommendations

For ‘non-PED’ work:

  • New welder qualifications: BS EN ISO 9606-1 should be followed in accordance with the requirements of the application standard
  • Existing welder qualifications to BS EN 287-1; confirm the certificate every 6-month according to Clause 9.2, when the certificate needs to be revalidated:
    • If the welder is re-tested: apply BS EN ISO 9606-1:2017
    • If the certificate is revalidated based on evidence of volumetric destructive or non-destructive testing (clause 9.3b): a new re-alignment sheet shall be prepared using the testing conditions shown on the existing qualification test certificate but applying the ranges specified in accordance with BS EN ISO 9606‑1:2017. The new alignment document shall indicate that revalidation is based on the ranges of BS EN ISO 9606-1:2017, 9.3 b). It may be a requirement that a Notified Body or Third Party Organisation verifies the document.

NOTE 2:  some methods of revalidation, such as Clause 9.3(c) in the standard ISO 9606-1, may not be permitted by certain application standards. When working to the requirements of an application standard, the welder qualification standard to be applied should be the one referenced in the application standard.

For ‘PED work’:

  1. In general, BS EN ISO 9606-1:2017 should be used
  2. When compliance with PED is required, but the applicable product standard still refers to EN 287-1 or an earlier version of ISO 9606-1 (eg EN 13445, EN 13480, EN 12952, etc):
  • If the reference to EN 287-1 is dated (for example, see EN 12952:2011), then BS EN 287-1 should be applied and the edition should be the one specified in the construction code.
  • If the reference to EN 287-1 is dated, but the standard addresses the use of EN ISO 9606-1 in lieu of EN 287-1 (see BS EN 13445:2014, Clause 2, footnote 1), then BS EN ISO 9606-1:2017 should be applied.
  • If the reference to EN 287-1 is not dated, then BS EN ISO 9606-1:2017 should be applied, as EN 287-1 is superseded and it was replaced by EN ISO 9606-1.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s